The Cost of Metal Roofing vs Shingles: An Overview

Cost Of Metal Roofing Vs. Shingles

Asphalt shingles tend to be less expensive upfront. On the other hand, metal roofing provides more long-term value since it lasts two to four times as long as the average asphalt shingle roofing system. On average, a homeowner should expect to pay 25-50% more for a metal roof than an asphalt shingle roofing system. However, ballparking a reasonable estimated cost for either option depends on numerous factors because a premium asphalt shingle roof might be more expensive than a budget-friendly metal roof.

The Dimensions Of Your Roof

When a roofing contractor prepares an estimate for the homeowner, they consider the roof’s dimensions. Naturally, a larger roof with more square footage requires more roofing materials and labor hours. A homeowner should expect to pay a higher price for a roof replacement if their roof is larger than average. Likewise, removing the existing roof may require more time and effort for demoing when it has more square footage. A roofing company may need to order an extra dumpster (or two) to dispose of the additional roofing material.

The Type Of Material Selected

If a homeowner wishes to install an asphalt shingle roof, they have many options. These choices include three-tab (traditional), architectural, and premium or designer styles. Three-tab shingles are typically the most affordable option, and the homeowner should expect to pay much more for premium or designer shingles. Within each style, every major manufacturer has one or more product lines. Naturally, every product line has its own pricing structure. The same cost analysis applies to metal roofing and the many available options.

The Prevailing Price For Labor

Local labor rates in a geographic area determine a significant portion of the roof replacement price. Regions with a higher cost of living will typically have higher labor rates. Additionally, a locale where labor is plentiful may have a reduced price of labor in that area. Specific geographical locations in the US typically have greater access to skilled roofing labor than others. This factor can override a higher cost of living to an extent, resulting in more affordable pricing for labor when replacing a roof.

The Chosen Roofing Contractor

Not all roofing companies are created equal. Roofers are not duty-bound to charge the same price for the same service. In fact, pricing depends on numerous considerations, including the contractor’s experience, availability, and reputation. A homeowner will typically pay a “premium” to hire an established or highly experienced roofing company. Most homeowners are willing to go this route if it means that the roofer will firmly stand behind their work with guarantees or other safeguards, usually in the form of a manufacturer’s or labor warranty.

The Complexity Of Your Roof

An intricately designed roof with many pitches, ridges, and valleys will require more roofing materials and labor hours than a “standard” gabled or A-frame roof. Likewise, if a roof contains many difficult-to-reach areas for which access requires special equipment, this will affect the roof replacement price. Additionally, if a roof contains many penetrations, including chimneys, vent pipes, and skylights, the installer must invest more time in attaching the new roof.

The Amount Of Overhead

The biggest unknown in a roof replacement cost is the extra expenses (overhead) that come with the project sticker tag. Naturally, every roofing company incorporates a profit margin into its pricing because its job is to make money. However, overhead expenses extend beyond this consideration. Local building codes generally require obtaining permits and securing inspections. Roofing suppliers may also impact the price, depending on their involvement in the project. Understanding these extra expenses can help homeowners feel more at ease about pricing.